Reasoning
The PTEN Expert Panel specification permits PS4 from either a sufficiently powered case-control study or phenotype-specificity scores. For case-control evidence, the governing text requires an odds ratio >2 for a PHTS component phenotype, p<0.05, and a 95% confidence-interval lower limit >1.5. For the phenotype-specificity route, adults contribute 1 point per proband with Cleveland Clinic score ≥30 or 0.5 points with score 25-29, and children contribute 1 point for pediatric phenotype score ≥5 or 0.5 points for score 4; strength is PS4_Very Strong at total score ≥16, PS4 at 4-15.5, PS4_Moderate at 2-3.5, and PS4_Supporting at 1-1.5. The case contains no documented proband phenotype, Cleveland Clinic score, pediatric score, case-control odds ratio, p-value, confidence interval, affected-case count, or control comparison, so no PS4 strength can be assigned. The PTEN specification also states that PS4 may not be applied if BS1 applies; BS1 is not evaluated in this group.
Rule
PTEN EP Version 3.2: case-control odds ratio >2 with p<0.05 and 95% confidence-interval lower limit >1.5, or phenotype-specificity score bands of ≥16 (very strong), 4-15.5 (strong), 2-3.5 (moderate), or 1-1.5 (supporting).
Evidence considered
- The ClinGen PTEN Expert Panel Version 3.2 specification states that PS4 may use a sufficiently powered case-control study with odds ratio >2, p<0.05, and 95% confidence-interval lower limit >1.5 for a PHTS component phenotype.
- The same specification defines phenotype-specificity scoring: adult Cleveland Clinic score ≥30 contributes 1 point, score 25-29 contributes 0.5 points, pediatric score ≥5 contributes 1 point, and score 4 contributes 0.5 points, with PS4 strength bands from supporting at 1-1.5 through very strong at ≥16.
- The case evidence contains no documented phenotype-specificity score or case-control enrichment result for NM_000314.8:c.-638C>T.
Still missing
- Documented affected probands and phenotype details
- Cleveland Clinic scores for adults or pediatric phenotype scores for children
- If using case-control evidence, odds ratio, p-value, 95% confidence interval, and affected/control counts
Sources