Reasoning
PVS1 is not met. The MANE Select transcript NM_001276270.2 places this substitution at c.-1, one nucleotide upstream of the coding start (c.1); it is therefore a 5′-UTR/Kozak-context change, not a nonsense, frameshift, initiation-codon, or canonical intronic ±1/2 splice-site variant. The normalized consequence is p.(=), and SpliceAI reports no predicted splice effect (maximum delta 0.00). Thus no premature termination codon, exon loss, NMD prediction, or protein-length change is established. MBD4 loss of function may be a disease mechanism, but that gene-level eligibility does not convert this non-null variant consequence into PVS1 evidence.
Rule
ClinGen SVI generic PVS1 recommendations (PMC6185798): apply only to a qualifying predicted null variant in a gene where loss of function is an established disease mechanism; c.-1G>A is not a canonical intronic splice-site or initiation-codon variant.
Evidence considered
- No MBD4 CSPEC/VCEP or local gene-specific PVS1 specification was available, so the ClinGen SVI generic PVS1 framework was used.
- The ClinGen SVI framework defines PVS1 for null variants, including nonsense, frameshift, canonical ±1/2 splice-site, initiation-codon, and exon-deletion variants, in a gene where loss of function is an established disease mechanism. It distinguishes canonical splice positions as intronic variants within one or two nucleotides of an exon.
- NM_001276270.2 is annotated as MANE Select in the case normalization data. The submitted c.-1G>A coordinate is upstream of the coding sequence, whose first coding nucleotide is c.1; the predicted protein consequence is NP_001263199.1:p.(=).
- SpliceAI reports DS_AG, DS_AL, DS_DG, and DS_DL of 0.00 (maximum delta 0.00), providing no computational evidence that this upstream substitution disrupts splicing.
- The gene-level PVS1 context supports MBD4 loss of function as a germline disease mechanism, but this prerequisite does not overcome the absence of a qualifying predicted null consequence for this variant.
Still missing
- No RNA or protein-expression/translation-initiation assay is available to determine whether the c.-1G>A 5′-UTR change alters MBD4 expression; such data could be relevant to other evidence types but would not make this variant a standard PVS1 null category without demonstrating a qualifying loss-of-function consequence.
Sources