Reasoning
PS3 is met at strong strength. No RAD51D-specific VCEP specification was available, so generic ACMG/AMP functional-evidence calibration applies. Ma et al. (PMID:33151324) evaluated the recurrent RAD51D K91fs variant, reported as 271_272insTA and equivalent to the case variant's normalized p.(Lys91IlefsTer13), in multiple orthogonal cell-based assays. Compared with RAD51D wild-type and empty-vector controls, K91fs reduced homologous-recombination repair in a DR-GFP reporter assay, impaired RAD51 recruitment to DNA-damage sites, failed to reduce gamma-H2AX foci after cisplatin treatment, reduced RAD51D protein stability, and increased olaparib sensitivity. The DR-GFP and gamma-H2AX experiments used three biological replicates with reported means and standard deviations and statistical testing; the assays directly interrogated RAD51D function and its established homologous-recombination role. This concordant, biologically relevant, multi-assay loss-of-function pattern supports strong PS3, although the publication uses the alternate insertion notation rather than the current transcript-level HGVS description.
Rule
Generic ACMG/AMP PS3: well-established functional studies supportive of a damaging effect; strong strength is justified here by concordant results from multiple orthogonal, biologically relevant assays with wild-type/empty-vector controls and replicated quantitative measurements.
Evidence considered
- The case variant normalizes to NP_002869.3:p.(Lys91IlefsTer13); PMID:33151324 evaluates RAD51D K91fs reported as 271_272insTA, the equivalent recurrent frameshift allele.
- In the DR-GFP reporter assay, RAD51D K91fs decreased GFP-positive cells compared with RAD51D wild type, indicating impaired homologous-recombination repair.
- In cisplatin-treated cells, RAD51D K91fs did not produce the wild-type reduction in gamma-H2AX foci, and mutant cells showed impaired RAD51 recruitment to DNA-damage sites.
- RAD51D K91fs had lower protein stability than wild type in cycloheximide time-course immunoblotting and increased olaparib sensitivity in BRCA-proficient TNBC cell lines.
- The DR-GFP and gamma-H2AX quantitative experiments used three biological replicates, means plus standard deviations, and two-tailed unpaired Student's t-tests; assays included wild-type and empty-vector controls.
- The functional endpoints are biologically relevant because RAD51D is an essential component of homologous-recombination repair, the established disease-relevant mechanism for RAD51D loss of function.
Sources